Testing the Social Justice Goals of Education: a Role for Anti-Discrimination Law

Loretta de Plevitz

doi:10.1017/S1326011100004762

Authors

Loretta de Plevitz Queensland University of Technology

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.1017/S1326011100004762

Abstract

Policy documents on Indigenous education include statements such as equitable access to education, participation and outcomes that can be broadly described as social justice goals. However, there has been little academic analysis of how these goals are to be achieved. This paper proposes that the indirect discrimination provisions in Australian anti-discrimination law can provide a framework in which the goals can be evaluated against the endemic effects of dominant power on mainstream education. The legal provisions are designed to assess whether a policy or practice might adversely affect certain groups in our society distinguished by, for example, their “race”. If a higher proportion of persons who do not have that particular attribute can comply with the policy or practice, and the demand is unreasonable in the circumstances, then this will constitute unlawful indirect discrimination. This paper analyses three social justice strategies which appear to be race-neutral and to apply equally to all students, Indigenous and non-Indigenous: Indigenous studies in the curriculum, using Standard English in the classroom, and instilling Australian values. The outcome suggests that these approaches may have an adverse impact on Indigenous students, and may even be undermining the social justice goals they set out to deliver.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

ABC Radio National. ( 2004, 11 November). Vanstone discusses Indigenous welfare shake-up [Radio broadcast]. In AM. Sydney, NSW: Australian Broadcasting Commission.

ABC Radio National. ( 2005a, 20 March). Senator Amanda Vanstone [Radio broadcast]. In Speaking out. Sydney, NSW: Australian Broadcasting Commission.

ABC Radio National. ( 2005b, 24 August). Teach Australian values or “ Clear off,” says Nelson [Radio broadcast]. In PM. Sydney, NSW: Australian Broadcasting Commission.

ABC Radio National. ( 2006, 1 June). Indigenous men respond: Interview with Dr Chris Sarra [Radio broadcast]. In Late night live. Sydney, NSW: Australian Broadcasting Commission.

Anti-Discrimination Act, 1991(Qld).

Australian Bureau of Statistics. ( 1996). Population issues, Indigenous Australians, 1996(Cat. No. 4708.0). Retrieved 21 March, 2007, from http://www.abs.gov.au/AUSSTATS/abs@.nsf/ProductsbyCatalogue/FC606c6C5A DB8EF5CA2570A800030EFl?OpenDocument.

Australian Government. ( 2005). Shared responsibility agreements. Retrieved 31 March, 2007, from http://www.indigenous.gov.au/sra.html.

Australian Government. ( 2006). Expense measures: Education, science and training[Budget Paper No. 2 (2006–7)]. Retrieved 21 March, 2007, from http://www.budget.gov.au/2006–07/bp2/html/bp2_expense-05.htm.

Cocks v State of Queensland. ( 1994). EOC 92– 612.

Department of Education, Science and Training. ( 2005). Nine values for Australian schooling. Retrieved 29 March, 2007, from http://www valueseducation.edu.au/values/default.asp?id=14515.

Department of Education, Science and Training. ( 2002–2006). National reports to parliament on Indigenous education and training, 2001–2004. Retrieved 31 March, 2007, from http://www.dest.gov.au/sectors/indigenous_education/publications_resources/.

Department of Employment, Education and Training. ( 1989). National Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander education policy. Canberra, ACT: Australian Government Printing Service.

de Plevitz L. ( 2006a). No school, no funds: Shared responsibility agreements and Indigenous education. Indigenous Law Bulletin, 6( 22), 16– 19.

de Plevitz L. ( 2006b). Special schooling for Indigenous students: A new form of racial discrimination? The Australian Journal of Indigenous Education, 35, 44– 53.

Downey P., & Hart V. ( 2005). Teaching and textual spaces in Indigenous education: A Murri School perspective. In Phillips J. & Lampert J. (Eds.), Introductory Indigenous studies in education: The importance of knowing(pp. 41– 59). Sydney NSW: Pearson Education Australia.

Eades D. ( 1992). Aboriginal English andthe law. Brisbane, QLD: Queensland Law Society.

Gerhardy v Brown. ( 1985). 159CLR 70.

Human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission. ( 2001). “ I want respect and equality”:A summary of consultations with civil society on racism in Australia. Retrieved 28 March, 2007, from http://www.hreoc.govau/racial_discrimination/consultations/consultations.html.

Human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission. ( 2004). Social justice and human rights for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people. Retrieved 31 March, 2007, from http://wwwhreoc.govau/socialJustice/info_sheet.html.

Hurst v State of Queensland. [ 2006]. FCAFC 100.

Indigenous Education (Targeted Assistance)Act, 2000 (Cth).

Johns G. ( 2006). Aboriginal education: Remote schools and the real economy. Canberra, ACT: Menzies Research Centre.

Mandla v Dowell Lee. [ 1983]. 2AC 548.

Ministerial Council on Education, Employment, Training and Youth Affairs. ( 1999). The Adelaide declaration on national goals for schooling in the twenty-first century. Retrieved 31 March, 2007, from http://www.dest.gov.au/sectors/school_education/policy_initiatives_reviews/national_goals_for_schooling_in_the_twenty_first_century.htm.

Northland Secondary College. ( 2005). College profile. Retrieved 24 March, 2007, from http://www.northland.vic.edu.au/contenl/content2.shtml.

Pearson N. ( 2007, 10 March). Noel Pearson: Native tongues imperilled [Opinion]. The Australian, n. p. Retrieved 31 March, 2007, from http://www.theaustralian.news.com.au/story/0,20867,21352767-7583,00.html.

Queensland Government, Department of Education and the Arts. ( 2005). Strategic Plan 2005–2009. Brisbane, QLD: Queensland Government Department of Education and the Arts.

Queensland Ministerial Advisory Committee for Educational Renewal. ( 2004). Noel Pearson: Native tongues imperilled [Opinion]. Report on Indigenous education: Recommendations to the Minister for Education and the Minister for the Arts. Brisbane, QLD: Queensland Government Department of Education and the Arts.

Racial Discrimination Act. 1975(Cth).

Sinnapanv State of Victoria.( 1994) EOC 92– 567.

State Housing Commission v Martin. ( 1999). EOC 92– 975.

United Nations. ( 1966). International Convention on the Elimination of all Forms of Racial Discrimination. Retrieved 3 June, 2007, from http://www.ohchr.org/english/law/cerd.htm.

United Nations Human Rights Council. ( 2006). United Nations declaration on the rights of Indigenous peoples. Retrieved 3 June, 2007, from http://www.ohchr.org/english/issues/indigenous/docs/declaration.doc.

Western Australian Aboriginal Child Health Survey. ( 2006). Improving the educational experiences ofAboriginal children and young people. Retrieved 21 March, 2007, from http://www.ichr.uwa.edu.au/waachs/publications/volume_three.lasso.

Zeegers M., Muir W., & Lin Z. ( 2003). The primacy of the mother tongue: Aboriginal literacy and non-standard English. The Australian Journal of Indigenous Education, 32, 51– 60.