Special Schooling for Indigenous Students: a New Form of Racial Discrimination?
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.1017/S1326011100004154Abstract
AbstractRecent reports on Indigenous education have revealed that high proportions of students have been placed in special classes for intellectual disability or behaviour disorders. This is not an isolated phenomenon. Indigenous students in Canada and Romani children in Europe are also disproportionately represented in special schooling. This paper asks whether systemic racism, which fails to perceive cultural differences between the ethos of Australian educational systems and the experiences and abilities of Indigenous students, is the catalyst for placing many Indigenous students in special schooling, away from the mainstream. The paper applies an analysis based on anti-discrimination law to argue that while allocation on the basis of intellectual disability or behaviour disorders may not be deliberate racism, the criteria developed for the allocation may be measuring conformity to the dominant culture. If the policies underlying this segregation are unreasonable in the circumstances, they could constitute indirect racial discrimination against Indigenous students. Educational authorities could be liable in law, even though the effect on Indigenous students is unintentional and said to be for the students’ “own good”.
Downloads
References
Action Travail des Femmes v Canadian National Railway Co, [ 1987] 1 SCR 1114.
Benson E. ( 2003) Intelligence across cultures: Research in Africa, Asia and Latin America is showing how culture and intelligence interact American Psychological Society Online Monitor on Psychology, Paper presented at the Aboriginal Studies Association and New South Wales Aboriginal Education 34( 2) Retrieved 5 August, 2006, from http://www.apa.org/monitor/feb03/intelligence.html.
Committee on the Elimination of Racial Discrimination( 2000, April) Intelligence across cultures: Research in Africa, Asia and Latin America is showing how culture and intelligence interact Reports submitted by States Parties under Article 9 of the Convention. Fourth periodic report of States parties due in 2000, Czech Republic. CERD/C/372/ Add.l, 14 April, 2000.
Cultural bias in intelligence testing, ( 2004) Retrieved 5 August, 2006, from http://www.wilderdom.com/personality/intelligenceCulturalBias.html.
DH and Others v the Czech Republic, no. 57325/00, [2006]ECHR 113.
Eades D. ( 1992). Aboriginal English and the law Brisbane: Queensland Law Society.
European Roma Rights Centre( 2004). Stigmata: Segregated schooling of Roma in Central and Eastern Europe Budapest, Hungary: European Roma Rights Centre.
Gale E. & Wundersitz J. ( 1989). The operation of hidden prejudice in precourt procedures: The case of Australian Aboriginal youth. Australian and New Zealand Journal of Criminology, 22( 1), 1– 21.
Gerhardy v Brown, ( 1985) 159 CLR 70.
Griggs v Duke PowerCo 401 US 424 ( 1971)
Hurst v State of Queensland[ 2006] FCAFC 100.
Hurst and Devlin v Education Queensland[ 2005] FCA405.
Johnson E. ( 1991). Royal Commission into Aboriginal Deaths in Custody: National report(vol. 2). Canberra: Australian Government Publishing Service.
L v Minister for Education for the State of Queensland( 1996) EOC 92-787.
Manila v Dowell Lee[ 1983] 2 AC 548.
Minister’s National Working Group on Education( 2002). Our children Keepers of the sacred knowledge: Final report Ottawa, Ontario:: Department of Indian Affairs and Northern Development. Retrieved 5 August, 2006, from http://dsp-psd.pwgsc.gc.ca/Collection/R4l-9-2002E.pdf.
New South Wales Aboriginal Education Consultative Group( 2004). Freeing the spirit: Dreaming an equal future (Yanigurra Muya: Ganggurrinyma Yaarri Guurulaw Yirringin.gurray)[Review of Aboriginal Education 2003- 2004] Darlinghurst, NSW: NSW Department of Education and Training.
New South Wales Department of Juvenile Justice( 2003). 2003 NSW young people in custody health survey: Key findings report Sydney: Department of Juvenile Justice.
Norris R. ( 2006). The more things change ...: Continuity in Australian Indigenous employment disadvantage 1788-1967. Unpublished PhD thesis, Griffith University, Brisbane.
Productivity Commission( 2006). Report on government services 2006: Part B education. Retrieved 5 August, 2006, from http://www.pc.gov.au/gsp/reports/rogs/2006/education/index.html.
Purvis v NSW Department of Education and Training[ 2003] HCA 62.
Queensland Ministerial Advisory Committee for Educational Renewal( 2004) Report on Indigenous education: Recommendations to the Minister for Education and the Minister for the Arts. Brisbane: Queensland Government Department of Education and the Arts,
Sinnapanv State of Victoria( 1994) EOC 92-567.
State Housing Commission v Martin( 1998) WASCA327.
Vinson T. ( 2002a). Inquiry into the provision of public education in New South Wales. First Report (May). Sydney: New South Wales Teachers Federation and the Federation of P&C Associations of New South Wales. Retrieved 5 August, 2006, from http://www.pub-ed-inquiry.org/reports/final_reports/FIRST_REPORT.pdf
Vinson T. ( 2002b). Inquiry into the provision of public education in New South Wales. Second Report (July). Sydney: New South Wales Teachers Federation and the Federation of P&C Associations of New South Wales. Retrieved 5 August, 2006, from http://www.pub-ed-inquiry.org/reports/final_reports/SECOND_REPORT.pdf
Vinson T. ( 2002c). Inquiry into the provision of public education in New South Wales. Third Report (September). Sydney: New South Wales Teachers Federation and the Federation of P&C Associations of New South Wales. Retrieved 5 August, 2006, from http://www.pub-ed-inquiry.org/reports/final_reports/THIRD_REPORT.pdf
Walker J. & McDonald D. ( 1995c). The over-representation of Indigenous people in custody in Australia[Trends and issues in crime and criminal justice Report No. 47]. Canberra: Australian Institute of Criminology
Waters v Public Transport Corporation( 1990) 173 CLR 349.
Wildsoet C.E., Wood J.M. & Hassan S. ( 1998). Development and validation of a visual acuity chart for Australian Aborigines and Torres Strait Islanders Optometry and Vision Science, 75, 806– 812.
Zeegers M., Muir W. & Lin Z. ( 2003). The primacy of the mother tongue: Aboriginal literacy and non-standard English. The Australian Journal of Indigenous Education, 32, 51– 60.
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2006 The Author(s)
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
The Australian Journal of Indigenous Education is in the process of transitioning to fully Open Access. Most articles are available as Open Access but some are currently Free Access whereby copyright still applies and if you wish to re-use the article permission will need to be sought from the copyright holder. This article's license terms are outlined at the URL above.
